Group Discussion for MBA Admissions

Group Discussion for MBA Admissions

The group discussion round conducted by MBA colleges like XLRI, MDI Gurgaon, SIBM Pune and IIFT is to assess the communication, knowledge and behaviour of the students. Previously, certain IIMs used to conduct the Group Discussion (GD) round as a part of their selection process. However, since then, all IIMs and some of the other B-schools have eliminated the Group Discussions round from their selection process, except for the Symbiosis Institute of Management and a few others.

Table of Content

  • + more items Show less

This is a significant step before admission into one of the top management institutes in India. 

During this round, a group of 6-8 students is given a topic, they discuss their views for 10-20 minutes and present their views on it. The topic can be about businesses, economy, environment, social practices or a case study.

The Group Discussion round holds a certain weightage in each MBA college, this might vary from one B school to another. The evaluators grade students on predefined criteria such as their leadership skills, interpersonal skills, knowledge, clarity and confidence. 

Group Discussion for MBA Admissions

What is the objective of Group Discussion?

  1. Evaluate leadership potential: The judges notice if the candidates are initiating the discussions. Confident leaders must not dominate or present extreme opinions. They instead maintain a meditative stance about any topic. The management field is for smart and diplomatic people.

  2. Test communication under pressure: In the Management field, there will be many instances when business leaders have to make decisions instantly. This step shortlists the students suited for MBA.  

  3. Assess teamwork and collaboration: The education in MBA colleges teaches students to work in teams. The GD round tests if the students can coexist with differing opinions, share a common space and build on each other’s ideas. 

  4. Gauge critical thinking: The topics given are such that the students are tested if they can think about the same topic from multiple perspectives. When questioned by a peer, will they be able to back their stance with a relevant example or data? 

  5. Emotional intelligence: This step tests how well students handle disagreements or counter opinions.  To perform well in this round, students should not evaluate any issue based on emotions. 

  6. Authenticity: The views presented by the candidates should be built on a personal level and ot just commonly held generic opinions. The speeches should not be memorised but should reflect genuine engagement. They promote natural thinking. 

  7. Filter incompatible candidates: The judges make sure to spot candidates who possess a strong ego or rigid opinions. Students must find the right balance between speaking and listening without interrupting their competitor’s speech. Those open to learning are selected through this round. 

Types of Group Discussions

1. Topical Group Discussion:

During the MBA selection Process, Topical Group Discussion is one of the most important types of GD. The candidates are provided with a topic, for example - the effect of pollution, traffic in metro areas, political corruption, India's non-aligned position, etc., then they will be asked to develop their ideas and present them in front of the group in the presence of a moderator. Here, the aim is to check the candidate’s social awareness and knowledge of current affairs along with their ability to raise and present the important points clearly and quickly. 

2. Case Studies Group Discussion:

This type of GD is also important. In this type, a case study or perhaps a real or hypothetical scenario is given to the group, and they are asked to work on it together and then discuss it. Their performance is judged on their ability to work as a team, understanding of the case and also on their analytical skills. Therefore, they aim to look for the qualities that the company manager possesses when they step into the leadership role. 

 3. Debate-based Group Discussion:

Debate-based group discussion is an interesting one. In this type of GD, students are assigned a topic on which they may disagree. In this discussion, the candidate will either agree or completely disagree with the candidates who spoke before them. Here, the candidate's persuasion skills, communication skills and manners, patience and knowledge of the subject etc. are evaluated. 

Important topics for Group Discussions

Current Affairs Topics

Social Affairs Topics

Business/ Economy Topics

COVID-19 Impact on Economy

Women’s Reservation in Parliament

Impact of the falling value of INR on India’s Economy

Lessons learnt from COVID-19

Girl Education in India

Minimum Support price: Genuine help or Political move

Impact of GST on Indian Direct Tax Collection

India dubbed the "capital of rape"—right or wrong?

Should the Indian economy be privatized?

Political situation in Bangladesh

New Education Policy

Statue of Unity: a symbol of national pride? 

Russia Ukraine War


Child Labour in India


Is an MBA necessary for success in the business field? 

Israel-Palestine Conflict

Liquor Ban: Is it Good or Bad?

Agriculture vs Manufacturing: which is key to the indian economy?

India-China relations in the last 10 years

Free Internet - Advantage or Disadvantage

Cahless Economy: is India ready?

Law and order in West Bengal

Traffic jams in metros

Demonetization: Success or failure


Violence in Manipur

Increasing Pollution Level: Reasons and Solutions

Is Technology a security threat for the Banking sector?

Amendment to Waqf Act

Higher Education in India: Bookish or Practical

How to prevent banking frauds to reduce NPAs

One nation, one election

Extra marks for girls – beneficial or detrimental?

Is ‘Make in india’ effective in boosting manufacturing

Abrogation of Article 370

Extra marks for non-engineers


Indus water treaty between India and Pakistan

Police reforms in the country



Amendment of Citizenship Act 2019

Money power in politics


Full Statehood to Delhi

Criminalisation of Politics


Full Statehood to J&K

Indian Population: Asset or Concern


National Register of Citizens

Delayed justice


Reservations more than 50%

Online revolution in India


Caste census

Benefits of Jan Dhan accounts in India


Dos and Don’ts for the Group Discussion Round

Dos 

Don’ts

Connect the ideas presented by others

Dominate everyone with individual opinions

Quality: present impactful ideas

Quantity: too many ideas, but all are generic

Cooperate/ Collaborate

Turn the discussion into a debate

Confidently shift stance if presented with knowledge

Be stubborn or rigid

Group Discussion vs Personal Interview

Group Discussions and Personal Interviews are conducted by many top MBA Colleges for admission into their management programs. Both rounds revolve around personality analysis and the depth of knowledge of the candidates. However, group discussion (GD round) tests an individual’s collaborative skills and how they perceive others, while a personal interview (PI round) reflects how they perceive themselves. The table shows the points of difference and highlights how MBA aspirants must behave during each round. 

Aspect 

Personal Interview (PI)

Group Discussion (GD)

Format

One-on-one/ Panel with the interviewer

A group of 6-8 people discussing a topic

Primary Focus

Individual background, goals and personality

Leadership, interpersonal skills and collaborative skills

Evaluation Criteria

Authenticity, career clarity, self-awareness, professional/academic credibility 

Team collaboration, listening skills, communication under pressure, in-depth knowledge and conflict resolution

Duration

10-30 minutes

10-20 minutes

Ideal Candidate trait

Authentic storyteller with clear goals

Balanced contributor who elevates the group

Common mistakes

Overconfidence/arrogance, lack of consistency in answers, lack of clarity on goals

Dominating discussions, aggressive rebuttals, silence or ignoring others

Role of the evaluator

Asks questions and probes responses

Observes the discussioncfe2f3s and provides scores accordingly